FREEMASONRY TODAY
Dangers of Electronic Banking
Fraud in banking can come in many forms,
as Mervyn Clarke warns
I often hear complaints about banks, but last month was quite an eye-opener on the aspects of banking-related fraud. Traditionally, the law has placed banks in the position of being strictly responsible for ensuring that cheques are correctly signed.
Electronic banking has changed all this and banks are often asking their customers to sign a “blanket” indemnity. People seem to sign these documents in blissful ignorance, trusting their bank, not realising that by doing so they may be letting the bank “off the hook”.
The electronic bulk payments system makes no provision for individual signature for individual payment. The trusting businessman approves a list of payments and his book-keeper does the rest.
But, just suppose your book-keeper suddenly has a financial crisis, or just gets greedy, and decides that a little “loan” would help.
So easy to alter a figure, or just make a “mistake” and pay a higher salary to himself, than his actual entitlement. The horror story continues and 12 months later a vigilant young auditor spots what is going on, by then heaven knows how much has been stolen. You are vulnerable! Here are some checks:
- Seriously consider if you really need to make your payments in this manner. Cheque-signing can at least give you some “come back” on the bank and makes you carry out security checks.
- If you use electronic banking, ensure that an independent person in authority checks the input.
- Make sure that the bank account is regularly and independently checked.
- Independently compare salary payments to personal records regularly and for each member of staff.
- Make sure that the book-keeper takes regular holidays and work is double-checked in his absence.
- Involve your auditors/accountants. Are they aware of these risks? If not get rid of them!
- Ask your accountant for a systems check and to advise you on the best ways of avoiding fraud.
Many readers in business who run limited companies know that the Government has recently increased audit exemption. We are, of course, cautious people and wary of statements made by politicians.
There is a great deal to be said for carrying on with your annual audit, even if you now fall below the audit exemption level. You could bless the day!
A good auditor should be able to advise you on your business systems and help you to avoid fraud risks and, of course, very often they discover fraud and error in the course of their work.
The independent check can pay for itself over and over. Don’t be fooled by the politicians. If Governments really want to cut back on the administrative costs on small businesses, there are very much better ways of doing it, e.g. National Insurance and Government forms.
Your accountant should explain to you about the importance of division of duties and independent checks. Many businesses lose huge amounts of money every year through lots of different types of fraud.
Businessmen often associate fraud with cash-based businesses (shops etc.), but there are huge amounts of frauds occurring based on collusion with suppliers, diversion of goods and bogus expense claims, not to mention the risks of electronic banking. Computerisation and electronic banking can, of course, be a tremendous boon to business if they are properly controlled.
Now to capital gains tax (CGT). A few weeks ago a lady came to see me. For many years her father lived in a house which she owned and provided rent-free. When he died, not surprisingly, the property showed a handsome profit on its original purchase price.
To my surprise her solicitor was apparently warning her of a large CGT liability. In short, the answer was “nonsense”. She owned the house before 1988 and provided it rent-free to a “dependent relative”.
Subject to checking Section 226 of the Capital Gains Tax 1992, it seems that she was completely exempt from CGT. Such provision of dependent relative accommodation is quite common, and it is worth checking if you comply with the section. You must check the “small print”.
A word of warning. Watch out where people have a documented right to live in the property, as this can attract Inheritance Tax problems. Follow the golden rule, get expert advice from a qualified tax specialist. Such a specialist is probably a Chartered Certified Accountant or Chartered Accountant.
Beware of unqualified people who call themselves “accountants”, financial advisers etc., many of them have dangerously limited knowledge.
Mervyn Clarke, FCCA is a Principal of Carlton Baker Clarke of Greenwood House, New London Road, Chelmsford, Essex, CM2 0PP. Tel: 01245 495588, Fax: 01245 495145.
Issue 14, Autumn 2000
|
© FreemasonryToday 1997-2008
|
|